Follow Rob Napolitano on LinkedIn

If you’ve been paying attention to financial headlines lately, you’ve probably heard a growing buzz about alternative investments. Big firms are promoting them everywhere—fancy brochures, slick ad campaigns, and podcasts galore. 

That said, here’s the uncomfortable truth most won’t tell you: many of these so-called “alternatives” behave a lot like the stock market. When things get shaky, they don’t provide the protection or diversification you’re probably hoping for.

So, what’s going on here?

The Problem: When “Alternatives” Act Like Stocks

The original idea behind alternative investments was simple:

Find assets that don’t move in lockstep with the stock market. When stocks go down, these investments should hold steady—or even go up.

Today’s popular alternatives—things like real estate funds offered by large firms, private credit funds packaged for easy access, or trendy “alt” ETFs—often fail to deliver on that promise. Why?

Because the way these investments are sold and who they’re sold to changes their behavior to mirror public markets.

Easier Access Means Emotional Investors

Big investment firms design these products for the masses, offering low minimums and easy exits. That sounds great until markets turn volatile. When that happens, many of the same investors who panic-sell their stocks do the exact same thing with their alternatives. That creates selling pressure and drives down prices—just like the stock market.

Liquidity Isn’t Always Your Friend

Real diversification often comes from investments that aren’t easy to sell. Why? Because illiquid investments force you to stay committed through ups and downs, which often leads to better long-term results. Modern alts with built-in liquidity invite short-term thinking and panic selling, eroding their intended benefits.

Designed to Feel Familiar—And That’s the Problem

To make these products easier to market, many firms design alternatives that still behave like traditional investments. They may hold assets tied to the economy or interest rates, which means when markets stumble, these “alts” stumble too.

A Better Approach: True Diversification with Private Placements

If you’re genuinely looking for something that behaves differently from the stock market, it may be time to look beyond the big-name alternative platforms. Private placements—investments in private businesses, real estate projects, or specialized funds—offer what many of today’s alternatives lack:

  • Low Correlation to Public Markets: These investments aren’t priced by daily market sentiment. Their value comes from real-world results, not stock market trends.
  • Illiquidity That Protects You From Yourself: Because you can’t easily sell out, you’re less likely to make emotional decisions that hurt your long-term outcomes.
  • Unique Opportunities You Won’t Find in a Mutual Fund or ETF: Private placements often involve niche markets and specialized strategies that aren’t tied to broader economic trends.

Of course, these investments aren’t for everyone. They require careful evaluation, a longer time horizon, and a willingness to commit capital for several years. That said, if you’re serious about adding real diversification to your portfolio, they’re worth exploring.

Final Thought

Fully integrated private investments are a hallmark of our work at Napier Financial. These opportunities are not only highly curated and vetted, but they are fully integrated into your personal financial planning objectives.

So, the next time you see a flashy ad campaign or hear someone talking about a trending “alt platform”, keep in mind that the better answer might be an alternative to the big alternatives.