Follow Thomas Schulte on LinkedIn
From time to time, I think of that insurance advertising campaign: “We know a thing or two because we’ve seen a thing or two.” Today’s topic–joint property–could have its own version of that chaotic ad series.
I’m about to share 10 slightly tongue-in-cheek examples of joint property gone wrong, but if you take away any lesson from this, it’s that joint property is only simple when life is simple. As we all know, life has a way of getting messy so if you have joint property, preventative planning is worth the effort. From real estate to heirlooms to businesses, there is no replacement for clear, legal documentation of rules and expectations.
With the serious part out of the way, here are 10 nameless examples of joint property gone wrong for your amusement (and reflection.)
1. Assuming Everyone Will Always Agree
At the start, it’s all sunshine and shared dreams. But fast forward a few years, and suddenly you’re in a heated debate about who really deserves the Fourth of July weekend. Spoiler: Without a clear decision-making process, nobody wins… except maybe your attorney.
2. Skipping the Legal Paperwork
Verbal promises are great–until they’re not. When real money and real estate are involved, a handshake won’t cut it. A written co-ownership agreement might feel more formal if needed for a family, but it’s the difference between a smooth exit and a courtroom drama.
3. No Way Out
People change their minds, get new jobs, or discover that “mountain living” in the family cabin isn’t as charming when winter rolls around. Without an exit plan, you could end up stuck owning half a property with someone who’s already mentally moved to Florida.
4. Unequal Contributions Without Accountability
One owner is painting fences and fixing leaky faucets; the other is in charge of morale support. Guess who feels resentful? Avoid this imbalance by clearly defining financial responsibilities and who’s handling what from the start.
This is especially important if siblings live varying distances from the real estate. It can be quickly assumed that the closer owners carry management responsibilities.
5. Ignoring Changes in Financial Situations
Life throws curveballs—job losses, divorces, or volatile business ideas that make the future impossible to predict. If one owner suddenly needs cash, things can get messy fast. Build in right-of-first-refusal clauses and financially feasible ways out of ownership if needed.
6. Overlooking Tax Implications
The IRS has a funny way of crashing every party. Rental income? Capital gains? Estate planning headaches? All of the above. When there’s more than one owner, keeping tax obligations straight is critical to avoiding finger pointing.
7. Failing to Set Clear Usage Rules
Without a calendar or agreement, you’ll end up in a passive-aggressive scheduling war. Trust us, few things create more awkwardness (or resentment) than finding out that a family member somehow claimed July 4th at the shore house for the 3rd year in a row.
8. Creating Unintended Legal Exposure
“I added my son to the house so there’s no estate tax when I pass.” Sounds clever—until your son’s creditors, lawsuits, or divorce lawyer show up with their own plans for your house. Joint ownership can open the door to legal and financial risks you never intended. Get advice before making ownership changes you can’t easily reverse.
9. Neglecting Maintenance and Repair Planning
It’s all fun and games until the roof leaks or the HVAC quits in July. Without a shared maintenance fund and plan, repairs become last-minute financial emergencies—or worse, the stuff of ongoing group text arguments. Better yet, consider endowing the property if you’re the one passing it down.
10. Assuming Selling Will Be Easy if Things Don’t Work Out
Real estate markets slow down, emotions run high, and agreeing on a sale price can feel like negotiating world peace. Set valuation methods and sale procedures now, before anyone starts packing.
